Episode 16: Fit for Crime (Part 2)

In this gripping two-part episode of Super SUS, we explore the unsettling and tragic story of Nicole VanderHeyden’s murder. Set against the backdrop of Green Bay, Wisconsin—a city celebrated for its Packers, not its crime—this case is a chilling tale of betrayal, resilience, and the relentless pursuit of justice that will keep you hooked until the very end.

A Community Upended

Nicole VanderHeyden was a devoted mother and a cherished part of her community. When she was brutally murdered just steps from her home, the entire city was shaken. The senseless tragedy sparked an intense investigation that exposed chilling betrayals and shocked even the most seasoned detectives.

Suspicion and Missteps

Initially, the focus landed on Nicole’s boyfriend, Doug Detrie. With a strained relationship and circumstantial evidence pointing his way, Doug became the prime suspect. But after spending 18 days in jail without any solid DNA evidence tying him to the crime, suspicions shifted. What unfolded next revealed a web of lies and a far more sinister truth.

The True Killer Emerges

The investigation eventually led to George Burch, a drifter with a shadowy past. When DNA evidence directly connected him to Nicole’s murder, Burch concocted an outlandish story, claiming a bizarre encounter and attempting to frame Doug for his crimes. His narrative unraveled as damning forensic evidence and cutting-edge technology painted a vivid and horrifying picture of what really happened.

Breakthroughs in Justice

Burch’s trial became a powerful testament to the role of technology in solving modern cases. Tools like cell phone tracking and Fitbit data pieced together an undeniable timeline, exposing Burch's lies and bringing clarity to a baffling and heartbreaking case. The jury saw through his desperate charade, delivering a just verdict and ensuring Nicole’s voice was not silenced.

Honoring Nicole

Nicole VanderHeyden was more than the victim of a tragedy—she was a light in her community, loved by those who knew her. Her life and legacy serve as a reminder of the importance of vigilance and justice. By sharing her story, we strive to honor her memory and bring awareness to the dangers that can exist right in our communities.

Lessons from Loss

This case underscores the power of perseverance and the role advanced technology plays in uncovering the truth. It’s a sobering insight into the darkness some people carry and a reassuring reminder that justice, no matter how elusive, can prevail.