Episode 04: Forget You Ever Knew Me

This week's episode of "Super Sus" takes us back to the 1950s, weaving a tale of mystery, intrigue, and unexpected twists on Halloween night. Tune in as we delve into the chilling murder of Peter Fabiano, a beauty salon owner whose life was ended by a late-night knock at the door.

Picture this: It’s October 31st, 1957, in Sun Valley, California. The air is filled with the excitement of Halloween, a night when anything seems possible. But for Peter, a 35-year-old World War II veteran, this festive night would end in tragedy. Known for his love of Halloween, Peter didn’t hesitate to answer the door for what he thought was a late-night trick-or-treater—only to be met with something far more sinister.

The investigation into Peter’s murder led detectives into a tangled web of relationships. At the heart of the story is a friendship between Betty Fabiano, Peter's wife, and Joan Rabel, an employee at Peter's salon. Their relationship, described in the 1950s as "abnormal," hints at the prejudices and social tensions of the time.

But the plot thickens with the arrival of Goldyne Pizer, a woman deeply infatuated with Joan. Under Joan’s persuasive influence, Goldyne found herself caught up in a deadly scheme, believing Peter to be a threat to her dear friend. In a moment of loyalty gone awry, she pulled the trigger, forever changing the lives intertwined in this complex love affair.

This episode doesn't just tell the story of a murder—it paints a picture of 1950s America, a time when societal norms were rigid, and whispers of forbidden love carried heavy consequences. As we unravel this tale, you’ll be struck by the dramatic moments reminiscent of a Hitchcock thriller—complete with disguises, deceit, and a chilling confession.

The consequences of that fateful Halloween night echoed through the years. Betty Fabiano managed to continue with her life, although shrouded in mystery as the case faded into obscurity. Meanwhile, Goldyne and Joan faced justice, albeit with a punishment as ambiguous as their original scheme.

We invite you to explore this intricate story of betrayal, deception, and the relentless pursuit of love. As always, we remind our listeners to stay safe, stay vigilant, and always be on the lookout for the "Super Sus."