Episode 24: In Plain Sight

In our latest episode of "Super SUS," we dive into the heart of Carrollton, Texas, where an ordinary day turned into a nightmare, unveiling a chilling tale of jealousy, obsession, and crime. The murder of 24-year-old Alyssa Ann Burkett in a parking lot not only horrified the small community nearby but also sparked questions about the boundaries of love and anger.

Morning of Horror

On October 2, 2020, the morning started like any other for Alyssa as she drove to her job at the Green Tree Apartments Leasing office. But just as she arrived, the ordinary turned fatal. Within moments, Alyssa found herself under attack by a mysterious figure clad in black, shattering her window with a gunshot and ultimately stabbing her 44 times. Left fighting for her life, she attempted to seek help from her colleagues, tragically succumbing to her injuries despite her courageous attempts at survival.

An Unexpected Suspect

The initial eyewitnesses described the assailant as a Black man—but Alyssa’s mother, Theresa, had her suspicions. She immediately pointed to Andrew Beard, Alyssa’s ex-partner and the father of her child, Willow, as the main suspect. Amidst a heated custody battle, Andrew’s relentless pursuit for full custody of Willow posed questions about his state of mind and possible motives.

Uncovered Truths

The investigation took a turn when Andrew's home and truck were searched, uncovering multiple incriminating items: burner phones, GPS tracking devices, and notes pointing to a pre-planned attempt to frame Alyssa with drugs and weapons found in her car earlier. It became clear that there was more to the story, highlighting Andrew's dangerous obsession.

From Denial to Confession

Despite his fiancée Holly's initial alibi, who vouched for him during the murder, the growing evidence became impossible to ignore. Andrew eventually confessed to the crime, admitting to his heinous actions that left a motherless child and a community in shock. His admission shook the very foundation of those who once believed in his innocence, including his supportive mother and fiancée.

A Case Unraveling

While Andrew awaits sentencing, the aftermath of his actions continue to unravel in surprising ways. The story leaves us questioning how well we can ever really know someone, and what drives a person to commit such an extreme act. Stay tuned for more on this unfolding case in the next episode of Super SUS.